IMPORTANT: This article analyzes a successful case resolved in accordance with the administrative, regulatory, and disciplinary framework in effect at the time of its publication. Currently, any disciplinary proceeding in sports must be reviewed based on the specific case, current case law, and Law 19/2007, of July 11,, against violence, racism, xenophobia, and intolerance in sports, and Royal Decree 203/2010, of February 26, which approves its implementing regulations.
IN DIEM Abogados secures a favorable administrative ruling for our client in disciplinary proceedings initiated for “sports violence,” in accordance with the provisions of Law 19/2007, of July 11, following a complaint filed by the Local Police during a soccer match at the Sevilla F.C. stadium .
In particular, the Government Delegation in Seville accepted our argument that a broad application of the violations defined in that law was not feasible and, consequently, withdrew the charge of a serious offense that could have resulted in a fine of up to 60,000.00 €, in addition to other ancillary penalties established in the aforementioned regulations. The Government Delegation in Seville therefore acknowledged that the serious offense did not apply to the alleged facts.
Disciplinary Proceedings for Violence in Sports: Favorable Ruling
The case raised a fundamental issue in the field of administrative penalty law: the need to interpret administrative violations strictly and to avoid broad or automatic applications when the alleged facts do not precisely fit the applicable offense.
In disciplinary proceedings related to sporting events, the Administration must carefully assess the facts, the available evidence, the alleged conduct, the proposed legal classification, and the proportionality of the sanction. The existence of a complaint or police report does not eliminate the need to establish the elements of the offense.
Law 19/2007 and Violence at Sporting Events
Law 19/2007 regulates the legal framework applicable to the prevention and punishment of conduct related to violence, racism, xenophobia, and intolerance in sports. This legislation addresses violations of varying severity and imposes penalties that may affect both the financial assets of the person sanctioned and their ability to access sports venues.
The penalties for such offenses may include fines, bans on attending sporting events, and other ancillary measures, depending on the severity of the offense and the assessment made by the authorities.
Precisely because of the severity of the potential consequences, it is essential that the government provide adequate justification for the charge and that the offense not be unduly extended to conduct that does not meet all of its requirements.
The Importance of Avoiding the Widespread Application of Penalties
One of the fundamental principles of administrative penalty law is the principle of legality. This means that penalties may only be imposed for conduct that clearly falls under an offense defined by law.
In this case, the argument put forward by IN DIEM Abogados focused on the fact that it was not appropriate to apply the violations set forth in the regulations on violence in sports in a broad manner. The Government Delegation in Seville accepted this position and withdrew the charge of a serious offense.
This point is particularly important because classifying the events as a serious offense could have resulted in a very high financial penalty and other additional consequences for the individual involved.
Legal Representation in Administrative Disciplinary Proceedings in Sports
Defending against disciplinary proceedings in sports requires a detailed review of the initial complaint, the statement of facts, the evidence included in the case file, the proposed sanction, the legal classification, and the proportionality of the proposed measure.
It is also important to verify whether the due process guarantees inherent in the disciplinary proceeding have been observed, including the right to a hearing, the presumption of innocence, the provision of reasons for the decision, the correct identification of the facts, and the proportionality between the alleged conduct and the disciplinary provision applied.
When the government seeks to impose a severe penalty, the defense must focus on both the facts and the legal characterization of the case. It is not enough to dispute the amount of the penalty; it may be necessary to challenge the very applicability of the alleged violation.
Financial Penalties and Additional Measures in the Field of Sports
Penalties for sports-related violence can have a significant impact on the person involved. In addition to a fine, there may be additional consequences, such as a ban on entering sports venues or restrictions related to certain events.
Therefore, upon receiving a complaint, a proposed sanction, or a decision to initiate proceedings, it is advisable to act quickly. The stage for submitting arguments can be decisive in presenting evidence, correcting the characterization of the facts, or preventing a disproportionate disciplinary charge from being finalized.
In this case, the withdrawal of the charge of serious misconduct made it possible to avoid a potential fine of up to €60,000.00 and the possible associated additional consequences.
A Success Story in Administrative Sports Disciplinary Law
The published case serves as an example of legal defense in the context of administrative sanction proceedings, where the dispute centered not only on the existence of a complaint, but also on the correct legal characterization of the facts and the limits of the Administration’s authority to impose sanctions.
For IN DIEM Abogados, cases of this nature require a technical analysis of the case file, the applicable regulations, and the safeguards inherent in the administrative sanctioning procedure.
The favorable ruling made it possible to avoid a finding of serious misconduct and confirmed the importance of a defense based on a strict interpretation of the grounds for disciplinary action.
Preguntas frecuentes sobre sanciones deportivas y procedimientos sancionadores
¿Qué es un procedimiento sancionador en el ámbito deportivo?
Es un expediente administrativo iniciado por hechos presuntamente relacionados con infracciones cometidas en el contexto de espectáculos deportivos. Puede derivar de denuncias policiales, incidentes en recintos deportivos o conductas producidas con ocasión de partidos o eventos deportivos.
¿Qué sanciones pueden imponerse en un expediente por violencia deportiva?
Según la gravedad de los hechos, pueden imponerse multas económicas y medidas accesorias, como la prohibición de acceso a recintos deportivos. La sanción concreta depende de la infracción imputada, la prueba disponible y las circunstancias del caso.
¿Puede recurrirse una sanción administrativa deportiva?
Sí. La persona afectada puede formular alegaciones, aportar prueba y, en su caso, interponer los recursos administrativos o judiciales que procedan. Es importante revisar el expediente desde el inicio para valorar la estrategia de defensa.
¿Qué importancia tiene que los hechos se califiquen como falta grave?
La calificación como falta grave puede aumentar de forma significativa la sanción económica y las consecuencias accesorias. Por eso resulta esencial comprobar si los hechos denunciados encajan realmente en el tipo infractor aplicado por la Administración.
¿Una denuncia policial basta para imponer una sanción?
La denuncia puede tener valor probatorio, pero la Administración debe tramitar el procedimiento con garantías, motivar la resolución y acreditar la conducta sancionada. La persona afectada puede discutir los hechos, la prueba y la calificación jurídica.
¿Cuándo conviene acudir a un abogado en un expediente sancionador deportivo?
Conviene acudir a un abogado desde la recepción de la denuncia, acuerdo de iniciación o propuesta de sanción. Una intervención temprana permite preparar alegaciones, aportar prueba y evitar una calificación jurídica desproporcionada.
Experts in disciplinary proceedings, sports law, and administrative defense
At IN DIEM Abogados, we provide legal advice and representation to individuals, professionals, organizations, and companies in proceedings related to administrative sanctions, sports law, disciplinary proceedings, sports-related violence, stadium bans, and administrative appeals.
Our team handles cases that require a detailed assessment of the administrative record, the initial complaint, the available evidence, and the applicable regulations. In these types of proceedings, legal counsel helps anticipate risks, organize the defense, and avoid disproportionate penalties.
- Legal representation in administrative disciplinary proceedings.
- Objections and Appeals Against Sports or Administrative Sanctions.
- Legal assistance in cases involving violence in sports.
- Challenging fines and ancillary measures, including access restrictions.
- Analysis of complaints, evidence, and legal characterization of the alleged facts.
If you have received a complaint, a proposed sanction, or an administrative decision related to sports or disciplinary matters, you can contact our team to receive an initial legal assessment.
In-person, online, and urgent service. 24-hour support.
IN DIEM Abogados provides in-person, online, and emergency legal assistance from its offices in Madrid, Seville, Málaga, Marbella, Estepona, Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, Almería, and Huelva, serving clients throughout Spain.
The firm has a multidisciplinary team composed of specialized attorneys and professionals with experience in the judicial, tax, commercial, technology, criminal, civil, administrative, and sports law fields, which allows us to approach each matter from a technical, strategic, and practical perspective.
In addition, IN DIEM Abogados offers urgent assistance when the nature of the matter requires an immediate response or a quick initial assessment of the case.
Would you like to know more about IN DIEM Abogados? Here is this short introductory video…
To acknowledge some of you, here’s this link.
You can find us in Seville, Madrid, Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, Málaga, Tomares, Coria del Río, Dos Hermanas, Mairena del Alcor, Estepona, Marbella, and Mairena del Aljarafe. We look forward to serving you.
